ARCHIVED NEWS
Researchers reveal ‘extremely serious’ vulnerabilities in e-voting machines
by Teresa Riordan · Posted Sept. 13, 2006
In a paper published on the Web today, a group of Princeton computer scientists
said they created demonstration vote-stealing software that can be installed
within a minute on a common electronic voting machine. The software can fraudulently
change vote counts without being detected.
“We have created and analyzed the code in the spirit of helping to guide
public officials so that they can make wise decisions about how to secure elections,” said
Edward Felten, the director of the Center for Information Technology Policy,
a new
center at Princeton University that addresses crucial issues at the intersection
of society and computer technology.
The paper appears on the Web site for the Center
for Information Technology Policy.
The researchers obtained the machine, a Diebold AccuVote-TS, from a private
party in May. They spent the summer analyzing the machine and developing the
vote-stealing demonstration.
“We found that the machine is vulnerable to a number of extremely serious
attacks that undermine the accuracy and credibility of the vote counts it produces,” wrote
Felten and his co-authors, graduate students Ariel Feldman and Alex
Halderman.
Edward
Felten (center), director of the Center for Information Technology Policy, has coauthored a paper
with graduate students Ariel Feldman (left) and Alex Halderman on a demonstration vote-stealing
software that highlights security vulnerabilities in electronic voting machines.
In a 10-minute video on their Web site, the researchers demonstrate how the
vote-stealing software works. The video shows the software sabotaging a mock
presidential election between George Washington and Benedict Arnold. Arnold
is reported as the winner even though Washington gets more votes. (The video
is edited from a longer continuously shot video; the long single-shot version
will be available for downloading from the center’s site as well.)
The researchers also demonstrate how the machines “are susceptible to
computer viruses that can spread themselves automatically and invisibly from
machine to machine during normal pre- and post-election activity.”
Felten said that policy-makers should be concerned about malicious software
infecting the Diebold AccuVote-TS and machines like it, from Diebold and other
companies.
“There is reason for concern about other machines as well, even though
our paper doesn’t directly evaluate them,” Felten said. “Jurisdictions
using these machines should think seriously about finding a backup system in
time for the November elections.”
Felten, a professor of computer science and public affairs who is known for
his groundbreaking work in
computer security, said that some of the problems discussed in the paper cannot
be fixed without completely redesigning the machine.
Other problems can be fixed by addressing software or electronic procedures. “But
time is short before the next election,” he said.
According to the researchers’ paper, the Diebold machine they examined
and another newer version are scheduled to be used in 357 U.S. counties representing
nearly 10 percent of all registered voters. About half those counties, including
all Maryland and Georgia, will use the exact machine examined by Felten’s
group.
Felten said that, out of security concerns, the Diebold machine infected with
the vote-stealing software has been kept under lock and key in a secret location.
“Unfortunately election fraud has a rich history from ballot stuffing
to dead people voting,” he said. “We want to make sure this doesn’t
fall into the wrong hands. We also want to make sure that policy-makers stay
a step ahead of those who might create similar software with ill intent.”
Princeton’s Center for Information Technology Policy includes members
from diverse departments, including computer science, economics, electrical
engineering, operations research and financial engineering, sociology and the
Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs.
|
RELATED LINKS
Center for Information Technology
Center to Address Societal Issues Driven by Technology
Q&A with Prof. Edward Felten
Princeton Alumni Weekly feature: "Who's Afraid of Alex Halderman?"
CONTACT
Please contact us to sign up for our mailing list, or the EQuad News, or to submit your news about research, teaching and events at Princeton Engineering.
For news outside of engineering, please see Princeton’s central
Office of Communications.
Engineering Communications Office
Princeton University
School of Engineering and Applied Science
EQuad, C222
Princeton, NJ 08542
For media relations, EQuad News, news releases:
|